The recent rebranding of CompTIA CASP+ to SecurityX highlights an opportunity to compare three advanced and recognized certifications. CISSP and CISM are well-known, but CASP+ hasn’t always enjoyed the same recognition. This rebranding may improve its reputation, which seems like a smart move.
I took the CompTIA Advanced Security Practitioner (CASP+) exam in 2022, and it was time and money well spent. The knowledge and skills required are comparable to CISSP, and I think it deserves the same recognition as Security+.
Next, I tackled the Certified Information Systems Security Professional (CISSP), known as the gold standard. It was the toughest of the three, but having already passed CASP+, I found it more manageable since they cover similar topics. Finally, I passed the Certified Information Security Manager (CISM), which focuses on management and governance. Compared to CASP+ and CISSP, it was easier but still valuable.
CompTIA Security X: The New Face of CASP+
CompTIA rebranded CASP+ as Security X to better reflect its focus on hands-on technical skills for advanced cybersecurity professionals.
Key Features:
- Focus: Advanced technical skills, risk management, and incident response.
- Audience: Technical leaders with 10+ years of experience (5+ in security).
- Exam: Performance-based and multiple-choice questions.
- Renewal: Every three years through education or retesting.
Pros:
- Hands-on focus.
- Vendor-neutral and versatile.
- Great for advanced technical roles.
Cons:
- Less emphasis on management and strategy.
- Not as well-known as CISSP or CISM (yet).
CISSP: The Gold Standard
CISSP, offered by ISC2, is a global benchmark for cybersecurity professionals, balancing technical skills and leadership.
Key Features:
- Focus: Covers eight domains, including risk management and security operations.
- Audience: Experienced professionals aiming for leadership roles.
- Experience: Requires 5+ years in two domains.
- Exam: Multiple-choice and scenario-based.
- Renewal: Every three years via Continuing Professional Education (CPE).
Pros:
- Recognized worldwide.
- Covers technical and strategic topics.
- Opens doors to senior roles.
Cons:
- Requires significant preparation.
- Less focus on hands-on skills.
CISM: Security Meets Strategy
CISM, from ISACA, focuses on governance and aligning security with business goals.
Key Features:
- Focus: Management, risk, and governance.
- Audience: Security managers and leaders.
- Experience: 5+ years in management.
- Exam: Multiple-choice.
- Renewal: Every three years via CPE credits.
Pros:
- Focuses on management and business alignment.
- Ideal for leadership roles.
- Globally recognized.
Cons:
- Limited technical content.
- Less relevant for hands-on practitioners.
Comparing the Certifications
| Feature | SecurityX | CISSP | CISM |
|---|---|---|---|
| Focus | Technical skills | Broad knowledge | Governance and strategy |
| Audience | Technical leaders | Senior practitioners | Managers and strategists |
| Experience | 10+ years (5+ security) | 5 years (2 domains) | 5 years (management) |
| Exam | Performance, MCQs | MCQs, scenarios | MCQs |
| Renewal | 3 years (CEUs) | 3 years (CPEs) | 3 years (CPEs) |
Which Certification is Right for You?
- Choose SecurityX if you’re a hands-on expert wanting advanced skills without a focus on management.
- Choose CISSP for a balanced certification that prepares you for leadership and technical roles.
- Choose CISM if you want to lead teams and align security with business goals.
Final Thoughts
Can certifications like SecurityX, CISSP, or CISM land you your dream job? They help, but experience matters just as much. Without experience, even advanced certifications may not be enough.